I have had the mis-fortune of dropping off an engine block for re-manufacturing at MJA Engineering in Broomgrove and want to warn other against this company as they really don’t know what they’re doing. I think it’s a case of “Don’t attribute to malice what is adequately explained by stupidity”.
I dropped off an SBC block at MJA Engineering to have it re-manufactured and bored over to become an 383 stroker. All seemed fine, they were friendly and appeared knowledgeable, no alarm bells ringing at this point. I picked the block up again, £940 lighter.
Upon inspection in my workshop, I noticed a scratch in one of the bores. It was black and you could feel it with your nail. You could also clearly feel the hone pattern with your fingers. Not being an expert, I posted the photo of the scratch on a forum. And yes, I know people on fora are not necessarily experts either, but feedback and discussion can still be helpful.
Everyone on the forum was in agreement though, and I even started PMing with a machinist about the honing. It was absolutely too rough for modern rings. MJA had used a grit (150) that was only fitting back in the days of steel rings.
I contacted MJA about this and they told me that:
- The scratch was not an issue and
- They had used that grit for two decades without issues
(They later admitted they did not have any stones above 150 grit and they don’t even appear to have a plateauing stone)
I obviously could not continue this build with 20 people (including two machinists) telling me this was badly wrong. I took it to another engine remanufacturing company who were quite shocked at MJA’s workmanship. They agreed to take on the block and sleeved the damaged cylinder and plateau-honed all the cylinders to a much better finish.
MJA’s work was just shockingly bad and ignorant. To make matters worse, their business card had the FER mark on it (Federation of Engine Re-Manufacturers) but when I contacted FER to complain, they said MJA were no longer a member. I queried the reason for this with MJA Engineering but they did not answer this question, so I can only assume they were expelled.
In short, don’t use MJA engineering in Broomsgrove, even if they were on TV. It doesn’t make them experts (clearly).